A controversial proposal made by JD(S) legislator MT Krishnappa during a session of the Karnataka Assembly on Tuesday has ignited a fierce debate over the state’s financial policies and welfare initiatives. Krishnappa, in a statement that many found shocking, suggested that the Congress-led government should distribute two free bottles of liquor per week to men, in a manner similar to the welfare schemes offered to women, such as Rs 2,000 monthly financial assistance, free electricity, and free bus travel.

Krishnappa’s Controversial Statement

During the session, Krishnappa defended his proposal, saying, "You (state government) are giving women Rs 2,000 per month, free electricity, and free bus travel. Anyway, it is our money. So, those who drink should be given two bottles of liquor free every week. Let them drink. What is wrong with that?" His comments immediately stirred anger and outrage, especially among women legislators, who criticized him for making such insensitive and generalized remarks.

Krishnappa’s suggestion was clearly intended to draw a parallel between the state’s welfare benefits for women and the potential for offering a similar benefit to male citizens in the form of alcohol. However, his choice of words and the nature of the proposal quickly became a focal point of criticism.

Backlash from Women Legislators and Ministers

Women legislators, in particular, were quick to respond, expressing strong disapproval of Krishnappa’s remarks. Energy Minister KJ George gave a sharp retort, saying, "You win the election, form the government, and do it. We are trying to make people drink less alcohol." His response highlighted the state government’s efforts to reduce alcohol consumption through various initiatives, contrasting them with Krishnappa’s suggestion, which many considered as promoting irresponsible behavior.

Personal Remarks and Escalating Controversy

Krishnappa further fueled the controversy by suggesting that many legislators consume alcohol and even took a personal dig at the drinking habits of a former legislator, as reported by India Today. These remarks were widely seen as tone-deaf and out of touch with the state government’s efforts to encourage responsible drinking and promote healthier lifestyles. His comments not only drew the ire of those who advocate for responsible alcohol consumption but also raised concerns about the overall approach to state welfare.

Opposition’s Criticism of Welfare Schemes

While welfare schemes like the Shakti Scheme and other financial assistance initiatives for women have been praised by many, the opposition in Karnataka has continuously criticized the government for the financial strain these schemes are placing on the state’s resources. The opposition argues that the state is incurring significant losses due to these welfare measures, leading to further discussions on the sustainability of such initiatives.

Krishnappa’s proposal adds fuel to this debate, with critics questioning the appropriateness of such welfare schemes and whether they align with the government's stated objectives, particularly regarding responsible behavior and public health.

The controversial proposal by MT Krishnappa has sparked a broader conversation about the balance between welfare measures, responsible behavior, and the promotion of healthier lifestyles in Karnataka. While the Congress-led government continues to defend its welfare schemes, emphasizing their importance for women’s empowerment and public welfare, Krishnappa’s remarks have clearly struck a nerve, leading to sharp political and social reactions. The debate over the state's welfare policies and their long-term impact is likely to continue in the coming weeks, with both the government and opposition voicing differing opinions on the matter.